Tuesday, February 09, 2021

Temple Tuesday: Revisiting That Hagen Girl



“That Hagen Girl” (1947) came to my attention when I saw Shirley Temple and Ronald Reagan together on the cover of the 1978 book, “The Fifty Worst Films of All Time.” Back in those days, ANYTHING that had Shirley on it found its way into my collection. Even as a fourteen-year old, I found this satirical book by Randy Dreyfuss and brothers Michael and Harry Medved to be hilarious.



There were very few films on this list that I had personally seen at the time, so I took their truly funny (albeit bitchy) text to be the gospel. These films must have really sucked! It wasn’t until about a year ago when I first watched “That Hagen Girl” for myself that I began to form my own opinion. While many regard it unfavorably, the truth is the film actually earned a modest profit when it was released. It is definitely not the box-office bomb that legend purports it to be. The story is about Mary Hagen (Temple), a teenager who is the subject of gossip in the little town of Jordan, where it is believed that she is the illegitimate child of Tom Bates (Reagan). What went wrong with this film that caused it to have a poor reputation? Let’s focus on what went RIGHT first, starting with the production team.


The score was by the legendary Franz Waxman. With twelve Oscar nominations and two wins (in consecutive years for “Sunset Boulevard” and “A Place in the Sun”), Warner Brothers was obviously not trying to go on the cheap with the music. Cinematography was by Karl Freund, who is probably best known for “Metropolis” and “Dracula,” as well as his work on “I Love Lucy” where he developed the “flat lighting” system that is still used today with sitcoms. “That Hagen Girl” is beautifully shot, which is hidden by most prints available today being in very poor shape; this movie is crying out for a restoration. Costumes were by Travilla, best known for Marilyn Monroe’s subway dress in “The Seven Year Itch” and Judy Garland’s notorious sequined pantsuit from “Valley of the Dolls.” Shirley certainly looks lovely in this film, and much of that credit goes to Travilla and makeup artist Perc Westmore, another legend in the business.



The cast is a more than solid lineup and includes Rory Calhoun, Jean Porter (who ably provides the much-needed levity in the film), Harry Davenport (grandpa in “Meet Me In St. Louis”), Moroni Olsen (who previously costarred with Shirley in “Susannah of the Mounties”), Lois Maxwell (the future Miss Moneypenny in the James Bond films, shown in the photo above), Conrad Janis (Mindy’s father on “Mork and Mindy”), Nella Walker (who worked with Shirley in “Change of Heart,” “Captain January” and “Kathleen”), and Kathryn Card (best known as Lucy’s mother in “I Love Lucy”). Standouts among this group include Maxwell as the supportive teacher, Janis as the slimeball who puts the moves on Shirley, and Walker as the snooty mother of Calhoun’s character.



The story is compelling; those who struggled as teenagers will be able to relate to the overwhelming challenges heaped on Mary Hagen. Even though she is a lovely, moral, and studious young girl, the town is hellbent on viewing her through the lens of the malicious gossip that surrounds her true parentage.

And the negatives of the film? The story is fairly heavy; there is little levity or break from the dramatic story of Mary Hagen. For those who are used to Shirley Temple movies, this one is definitely a deviation from the norm, which is why Shirley truly enjoyed making it. As she recalled in her autobiography Child Star:

Lots could be done with the role, a lip-smacking case history of an adopted, illegitimate girl in a small town. Gossip and taunts bloom into total social ostracism and culminate in her attempted suicide.



Then there is a gallant rescue and eventual happy marriage to a man long suspected of being her father. For convoluted plots, this one bulged and groaned. But therein lay opportunity.

The somewhat wooden performance of Shirley’s leading man, Ronald Reagan, shows that he was definitely not a willing participant in the film. Shirley recalled:

Reagan is reported to have detested the script, which cast him in the ridiculous position of first being rumored my father, then my lover. Jack Warner apparently brushed his objections aside, advising Regan that as a contract player he do it or face suspension.

Yes, the father-then-lover aspect of the story does give a bit of an “ick” factor, which could have been handled better, perhaps by letting the audience know early on that Reagan’s character was definitely not Mary Hagen’s dad. Instead, the possibility lingers on until the very end when it is finally revealed, just before the two lovebirds leave town on a train together. A little too much too late. The age difference between Fred Astaire and Judy Garland in “Easter Parade” doesn’t present a problem because of Astaire’s charisma and charm, and the obvious professional chemistry between the two actors. In “That Hagen Girl,” Reagan shows a definite lack of charm or real chemistry with Shirley, which is especially problematic for the happy ending. 



Is it the turkey that Medved and Company reported back in the 1970’s? Definitely not. It is a solid little film that definitely deserves a re-evaluation. Shirley’s “A Kiss for Corliss” (1949) is a different story...but that’s for another post!

See more “That Hagen Girl” photos at my main website.

Monday, February 08, 2021

Monday on the Island


You were probably thinking about a tropical island. Not here at Daveland; instead, let’s visit Tom Sawyer’s Island. There’s so much more to do there. In this 1958 image, you can zoom in and see guests actually fishing at Disneyland…for real live fish! Just stick that in your purse until we get home, mom.


Another detailed view shows guests on the raft that transported them back to the Park.


One year earlier in December 1957 shows a Keel Boat on the left…


and guests paddling a canoe. Chop, chop! You’ve got to get all the way around the Island, folks!


Also from the same December 1957 photographer comes this second view of the Island showing the fishing pier…


and Tom and Huck’s Tree House. What little kid didn’t enjoy climbing up to the top of that?


Want to know what you could see from there?


In December 1958 you could view the Chicken Plantation Restaurant. Is it time for lunch yet?


See more Disneyland Tom Sawyer Island photos at my main website.

Thursday, February 04, 2021

Further Tales from David M.


Former cast member David M. gave me MORE great stories to share from his days at Disneyland. Enjoy!

Tales from the Park

One time, my supervisor called me from my duties on Tom Sawyer Island to help supervise the Main Street Parade. He told me that my one duty was to keep people from climbing onto the raised flower beds near the entrance to Tomorrowland in order to get a better view of the parade. So, in my Cavalry Trooper uniform, I stood at my assigned station and soon, sure enough, a woman had climbed onto the flower bed and was trampling the petunias. I politely asked that she step down whereupon she replied that she couldn’t see the parade from street-level. I told her that nonetheless, she was killing our flowers and she had to step down. She replied, “You son of a bitch.” I said, “Yes, ma’am, that may well be, but you still have to get down from that flower bed.” She complied, and another guest who had watched the whole thing, said, “Buddy, well done – but I wouldn’t want your job.”


 A few weeks later, my supervisor again called me off the Island with an unusual duty. It seems that someone in Entertainment thought it would be fun to have The Big Bad Wolf (who wore loud and intimidating cleats on his shoes) march the Three Little Pigs though the park. The Pigs would be in front with the Wolf following – and with a big club slung over his shoulder. The problem was that little kids hated the wolf and they would come up behind him and kick him in his tail and legs, which of course could be painful. My job was, in my Cavalry Trooper uniform, to follow closely behind the Wolf and protect him from the mean kids.


 And speaking of the Three Little Pigs: girls in the know always stayed away from them. Why? Well, because the Pig costumes were made in such a way that the body and the head of the Pig’s ended at the shoulders of the actor inside, with the actor’s head above & inside the Pig’s hat with the hat made of a black gauze material so he could see out. The Pigs all had the job of merrily wandering the Park (at least when the Wolf was not herding them) and happily bouncing into guests. Well, few people knew that the Pig’s nose was as flexible and soft and the actor inside could put his hand inside, almost as if inside a glove and the nose thus became an appendage. This resulted in many a female guest’s being bumped into and providing the actor inside the Pig costume with the proverbial “free feel.”


I also heard from fellow staff who supervised Monsanto’s Ride Through Inner Space in Tomorrowland that when viewing the attraction through unseen slits in the set, that they would see some pretty heavy make-out sessions between the start and the end of the ride through the attraction.

See more vintage and contemporary Disneyland photos at my main website.

Wednesday, February 03, 2021

Back to Catalina, Pt. 4


Welcome back to my Catalina Island series; as you head towards the Casino/Theatre, you pass these really cool tiles. This particular one depicts the Casino:


I LOVE the colors of these Catalina Tiles! Created by Catalina Classic Tile, they are a signature of the Island.


The Catalina Casino opened on May 29, 1929. Its Art Deco/Mediterranean design was by Sumner Spaulding (designer of the famed Harold Lloyd estate, Greenacres) and Walter Weber. The casino's movie theater was the first to be designed specifically for films with sound. It received the Honor Award from the California Chapter of the American Institute of Architects, as “one of the outstanding architectural accomplishments.”


Although available for tours, the movie theatre has ceased to function due to low attendance.



It was closed during my visit, so the only interior shot I got was this one through the glass doors:


These interior shots were from 2004 when I saw a movie there:




Back to the present, and some incredible vintage light fixtures!


The tile in the entry:


One more installment left in my Catalina series!

See more Catalina photos at my main website.

Tuesday, February 02, 2021

Temple Tuesday: Shirley's Got Mail


In this 1943 photo, Shirley Temple checks to see what’s in her mailbox at her Rockingham Avenue home in Brentwood:


From the same photo shoot, Shirley relaxes by the lily pond outside the flagstone patio near the entrance to the home:


Was the water really cold, or was Shirley just tired of having her photo snapped?


Today, this is the less-than-exciting mailbox one sees in front of the former Temple residence:


The home still remains, although the house (and the property) was subdivided many years ago and now consists of three parcels:


Melissa (aka “The Colonel”) and Army members Shirley Jean and Mary were fortunate enough to get to tour the home during their last visit to California:


I wonder if they checked the mailbox?

See more Shirley Temple photos at my main website.

Monday, February 01, 2021

Fear and Snow White


I was very excited to acquire this 1956 vintage image of the Snow White and Her Adventures entrance area. Zooming in you can see the original mural that adorned the queue area:


Where the Pinocchio dark ride now resides, you could have gotten a Welch’s Grape Juice beverage to cool off with during those hot Anaheim summer days!


The name Snow White’s Scary Adventure did not get used at Disneyland until the 1983 remodel. Apparently the Imagineers felt that the little tykes needed a warning about the scary portions of the attraction that included the Old Crone. Recently, Imagineers felt it necessary to remove the scare all together by tinkering with the attraction and changing the final scene to a happy ending. From the Disney Parks Blog:

This classic Fantasyland attraction, Disneyland park’s only ride-through princess attraction, will be updated with new magic inside and out in 2020. Walt Disney Imagineering is reimagining how the classic tale of Snow White lives happily ever after, and guests will be invited to follow along with her story.

One reader left this comment:

Hope they’ll just lengthen the ride for the new scenes in place of the “and they lived happily ever after” murals and still leave all the existing scenes in tact.

To quote Burgess Meredith from “Grumpy Old Men”:


Since the Park is still closed, it’s not really known exactly how much of the scare has been removed. Let’s take a look at some of the elements that could be under the chopping block, beginning with the Evil Queen peering out over guests from the exterior (much more menacing at night!):


The Evil Queen doing a Peeping Tom act at the Dwarf’s Cottage as the seven little men celebrate with Snow:


The transformation scene of the Evil Queen turning into the Old Crone:


Will this hanging skeleton be allowed to remain?


The Old Crone creating the poison apple:


The Old Crone and her apples sailing off to the Dwarf’s cottage:


The Old Crone and a hologram apple, appearing from inside the Dwarf’s cottage:


The original finale of the Dwarfs attempting to capture the Old Crone as she escapes:


The Old Crone attempts to kill the Dwarfs with a boulder:


…which ends up killing her when a bolt of lightning hits the rocks:


Bye bye Old Crone!


From the way the changes have been positioned, it sounds like much of the ride has been softened. This really makes me sad. I know as a kid I secretly LOVED being scared! What would “The Wizard of Oz” have been without the Wicked Witch? BORING! 


The original “Willy Wonka” movie would have been a snoozer without Gene Wilder’s crazy and sometimes menacing portrayal.


Wilder himself said he only accepted the role because he was allowed to make the viewer feel uncertain if the Wonka character was trustworthy or not, starting off with his entrance scene where he pretends to limp. Even his final scene where he loses his s$%t with Charlie…BRILLIANT! Let’s face it…kids love to be scared. Why oh why does Disney feel the need to protect the kiddies by removing the very thing that they love?

I know I know…Lowest Common Dumb-nominator.

See more Disneyland Snow White attraction photos at my main website.