Temple Tuesday: Photoplay Fluff, February 1938

Fluff media is nothing new; back in the 1930s, instead of browsing websites, people thumbed through the monthly movie magazines to find out what was going on in Holly-weird. In the February 1938 issue of Photoplay, Shirley Temple was shown in a two-page photo spread titled “Shirley kneads the dough” attempting to make biscuits in the kitchen of her family’s Brentwood home.



With her usual verve and vitality little Miss T. tackles the higher complications of the culinary arts.



She gets flour in her eyes, but that doesn’t floor her for there’s Pekingese Ching-Ching, her all-time friend, to blink in absolute approval. Determination, self-reliance, persistence giver her, in the kitchen as before the camera—perfection.



Just in case you wanted to see the exterior of Shirley’s quaint residence…



Elsewhere in the issue was a slightly more substantial article about “high finances” in Tinseltown by writer and pop culture analyst Gilbert Seldes.



A short time ago the script on which Shirley Temple was working called for a pony. In Hollywood you can get a pony at least as easily as a rhinoceros, but the director was in a hurry—and there was a pony on the set. Miss Temple’s own pony. And she let him use her pony—at ten cents a day. That’s pleasing thing to know and gives you a warm feeling about the little girl. Older — but not necessarily better — actors and actresses earn larger sums in other ways, sometimes without showing as much business sense as Miss Temple did. They earn their pin money—diamond pin money—in a thousand enterprises. There is hardly a business, from canned goods to the prize ring, in which some player is not represented. In fact, when you see how much money they make when they are not working, you sometimes wonder why moving-picture stars trouble to act at all. This is not an invitation to any nasty remark that most of them can’t act. You, and I, and the gentlemen in the Income Tax Bureau know that Shirley Temple earns about fifteen times as much money on by-products as she gets from Twentieth Century-Fox…Yet, without the movies, little Miss Temple might have put her name on the manna from heaven, or on the original waters of the Fountain of Youth for a face lotion, and she would not have received a cent in return. And this goes for all the others.…For myself, I still think that Miss Temple’s ten cents is the best money in the world. It was earnred by straight business methods (the little girl is a rugged individualist) and she probably would be a great executive if she weren’t so busy being an actress. The other money on the side is velvet—her dime for the pony is earned—and, I hope, well spent.
 
See more photos of Shirley Temple at home at my main website.

Marilyn's Manse: To Save Or Not To Save

More than sixty years after her death, actress Marilyn Monroe is still making headlines. The one residence that she owned (and where she passed) at 12305 Fifth Helena Drive in Brentwood, California was destined for demolition by its current owners. The one-story, 2,900 square foot Hacienda-style home was built in 1929, three years after Marilyn was born.



According to Architectural Digest:

The 2,900-square-foot, one-story, L-shaped, Spanish colonial-style home had adobe walls and a red-tile roof and was protected by a high wall. It had two bedrooms, a small guesthouse, an oval swimming pool and a large garden. The interior had white stucco walls, white carpeting, cathedral beam ceilings and tiled fireplaces in both the living room and master bedroom. Monroe bought some essential furnishings on shopping trips to Tijuana and Mexico City: tiles for the kitchen, tin masks and mirrors for the walls, and textiles depicting Aztec figures. But the house was sparsely furnished, and her phonograph remained on the floor.



She called it “a cute little Mexican-style house with eight rooms” and regretfully added, “I live alone and I hate it!” She loved animals and had always been fond of pets, who soothed her loneliness. Frank Sinatra gave her a white poodle called Maf (short for Mafia), whose name referenced his mob connections. Proud of the house and the improvements she made, she keenly showed visitors around and called it a “fortress where I can feel safe from the world.”

In an eerie case of foreshadowing, the tiles on the front doorstep say, “Cursum Perficio,” which translates to “I have completed my journey.”



From Curbed LA, April 20, 2017, when the house was put up for sale:

Before her death, a reporter with Life magazine spent a day with Monroe in the home, telling him, “Anybody who likes my house, I am sure I will get along with.” She had “[thrown] herself into making a home for herself. She planted an herb garden and in early 1962 traveled to Mexico to purchase authentic furniture, art and tapestries for her new home,” according to Variety. Listing agent Lisa Optican said it, “retains many of the design elements selected by Monroe.” “When you walk the house and grounds, you’re immediately struck by its serenity and warmth,” she said. “Every owner who has called this property home has been drawn to the same character ... The property is romantic, intimate and private.”

The now defunct Mercervine brokerage website (due to bankruptcy), reported the sale on June 23, 2017:

Mercer Vine’s Lisa Optican has sold 12305 5th Helena Drive in Los Angeles’ Brentwood neighborhood for over asking price at $7.25 million.
 
Considering Marilyn bought the house for $77,500, that would have been quite an investment for her!



Set back from the road enough to make it difficult to view, Marilyn’s house was still a place where fans would do their “looky-loo” thing to the annoyance of the owners and neighbors. And then the unthinkable happened — the threat of demolition. Edited from the Robb Report on September 6, 2023:

It’s another sad day for fans of historic architecture and Old Hollywood lore alike. As first reported by the New York Post, the house located at 12305 Fifth Helena Drive in L.A.’s Brentwood neighborhood, a 1920s Spanish hacienda-style structure, may soon be demolished by its new owner. Despite its modest scale and unpretentious nature, the 2,600-square-foot bungalow gained worldwide fame in 1962 as the location of Marilyn Monroe’s sudden death. The walled and gated property was also the only house ever owned by the legendary actress, and in the six decades since the half-acre estate has become one of the city’s most famous local landmarks.…While the home’s exterior architecture remains incredibly alike how it appeared in 1962, the interiors have been significantly altered. Most notably, the kitchen and bathrooms have been modernized, and the estate’s formerly detached guest casita has been merged into the main house. Still, numerous original features — casement windows, terracotta tile floors, wood-beamed ceilings — happily hark back to Golden Age times. Out back, a brick patio spills out to a notably large swimming pool; beyond that, a grassy lawn is surrounded by mature trees, tall hedges and a citrus orchard. Out front, bountiful bunches of bougainvillea arch their way across the home’s façade, and there’s a two-car garage. Teardowns have become increasingly commonplace in the area surrounding Monroe’s former home, as soaring property values and record-breaking sales entice developers to build ever bigger and fancier. That this particular property survived intact is a testament to the hacienda’s enduring charm, and to Monroe’s legendary status, of course. Back in 2014, Emerald Lake hedge fund manager Dan Lukas and his wife Anne Jarmain paid $7.3 million for the Monroe estate, and have lived at the property in the years since. Six months ago, however, the couple paid $13 million for a larger home in the same neighborhood. Last month, Lukas and Jarmain quietly sold the Monroe house to a buyer who has not yet been publicly identified. That person paid nearly $8.4 million for the property, in cash, and almost immediately applied for a demolition permit. The L.A. Department of Building and Safety recently approved the request for a “plan check” of the proposed work, though an official permit has not yet been issued. But if similar situations in the recent past are any indicator of this property’s future, it seems likely that the Monroe hacienda will soon be added to a long list of historical real estate treasures that continue to be lost.

Shortly after the news broke, a Change.org petition started, requesting that the City convert the house to a museum:

This house should become a museum in memory of Marilyn Monroe for visitors, tourists and fans. Like they did with Elvis Presley’s house named “Graceland,” who has been transformed into a museum in his memory.

The news even made it to Vanity Fair. Edited from their September 9, 2023 article:

…[I]t’s a building that a shadowy and nameless owner almost destroyed until the Los Angeles City Council stepped in to stop it. News that the owner of 12305 Fifth Helena Drive wanted to destroy the home spread quickly this week after the New York Post reported that it was in “the initial stages of the demolition process.” The four-bedroom, three-bath Spanish Colonial hacienda, which Monroe bought for $75,000 as her third marriage, with playwright Arthur Miller, came to its end, had been evaluated for landmark status in 2013, but that process stalled, despite it being—as movie producer and neighbor Rodney Liber put it to the LA Times—“one of the most famous houses in the world.” That famous house was sold in 2017 to an LLC called Glory of the Snow for $7.25 million; in July, it was sold to the similarly named Glory of the Snow Trust for $8.35 million, the LAT reports. However, the actual humans behind the company names are unclear. The LLC was managed by Emerald Lake hedge fund manager Dan Lukas and his wife Anne Jarmain. The trust names a person called “Andrew Sahure” as its trustee, but that's a moniker which boasts no Google or public records results beyond this matter. (Gardners will note, however, that “glory of the snow” is the common name for chionodoxa luciliae, a spring-blooming perennial known for its purple flowers. Do with that what you may.) It’s unclear if anyone currently lives in the house, or why its owners want to destroy it, but as news spread of the plan, neighbors and preservationists sprang into action. A spokesperson for LA Councilwoman Traci Park says that their office received “hundreds of calls” asking her to step in, Reuters reports. And step in she did, introducing a council motion Friday asking the city’s Cultural Heritage Commission (CHC) to consider the home for inclusion in LA’s list of historic cultural monuments. The motion was approved unanimously, giving the CHC 75 days to evaluate and approve the house as a landmark.



In response, LA’s Board of Building and Safety Commissioners paused any potential work at the site, saying in a letter to the owners that the preliminary approval for demolition was “issued in error.” “Under the Cultural Heritage Ordinance, this action immediately triggers a temporary stay on all building permits while the matter is under consideration by the Cultural Heritage Commission and City Council,“ KTLA reports the letter as reading. “Also, the property, regardless of whether a permit exists or does not exist, shall not be demolished, substantially altered or removed.”“This will be the first step in ensuring that we can protect this home against demolition,” Park told ABC 7. “The overwhelming sentiment here is clear. This home must be preserved as a crucial piece of Hollywood’s and the city of Los Angeles’ history, culture and legacy.”

Nearly a year later on June 26, 2024, Variety reported an update on the situation:

Marilyn Monroe‘s house in Los Angeles’ Brentwood neighborhood was approved in its historical cultural monument nomination by the Los Angeles City Council on Wednesday, a designation which is intended to help protect the landmark from demolition. “The Marilyn Monroe Residence in Brentwood is now a Historic-Cultural Monument! Today, L.A. City Council unanimously approved the nomination for Marilyn Monroe’s final home. Thanks to all who voiced their support and a HUGE thanks to Councilwoman Traci Park & team!,” wrote the L.A. Conservancy on X. …Owners Brinah Milstein and her husband, reality TV producer Roy Bank, bought the house last year for $8.35 million and planned to demolish it to expand their property next door. They waged a year-long battle to stop the historical designation, which they said would lead to more nuisance visitors. The owners have sued the city, accusing officials of “backroom machinations,” and the case is due to get a trial date on Aug. 13. In the suit, the owners say that the house has been substantially altered and that there is no evidence remaining from the time when Monroe lived there, so they contend it does not meet the criteria for a historic cultural monument.



The suit also says that several neighborhood groups and the Monroe estate did not support the historic designation. The council’s vote was 12 to 0 in favor of adding the house to properties of historical significance. The decision was backed by the City Council’s land use management subcommittee and the Cultural Heritage Commission. While the designation doesn’t completely stop a property from being demolished, the status subjects it to a stringent review process if demolition were proposed. L.A. City Council member Traci Park said before the vote, “We have an opportunity to do something today that should’ve been done 60 years ago. There’s no other person or place in the city of Los Angeles as iconic as Marilyn Monroe and her Brentwood home.” In response to the vote, Milstein’s attorney Peter C. Sheridan, who also represents the owner’s Glory of the Snow 1031 Trust and Roy Bank, released the following statement. Council Member Traci Park, in bringing a motion to designate the former home of Marilyn Monroe as a Historic Cultural Monument, said she has “worked closely” with the owners “throughout this process” to relocate this house to allow for public access. This is not true. Neither she nor her staff have worked closely with the owners, throughout this process or anytime else, to relocate the house to allow for public access. In fact, the opposite is true. The owners have made countless attempts to work with Ms. Park and her staff to find a solution that would work for everyone, only to be met with non-responsiveness by Ms. Park and her staff. Ms. Park has ignored the fact that her constituents — civic and homeowner’s groups in the community — are adamantly against the designation of the home. Ms. Park has also ignored that the City granted dozens of permits to over 14 different prior owners to change the home through numerous remodels, resulting in there being nothing left reflecting Ms. Monroe’s brief time there 60 years ago. The designation today was yet another step in an admittedly biased, unconstitutional and rigged process, as set forth in the owners’ lawsuit. Traci Park’s actions today and throughout the process, disregarding the interests of her constituents and the facts and merits, demonstrate that no one’s home or investment is safe.



Although there was an online celebration about the landmark status being achieved, it would seem that the home is far from being safe. I have mixed feelings about the whole thing. Marilyn doesn’t live there anymore, and based on photos and what I have read, a lot of work would need to be done to return the home back to the state it was in when Marilyn lived there for six short months. The quiet neighborhood would not be an ideal place for a museum, where traffic and tourists would be a constant annoyance. If the home is to be moved elsewhere, then it loses the geographic significance that attracted Marilyn in the first place. Even if a group was able to buy the home, would they also have the money to keep it going?

Time will tell, and within a month we should all know more.

See more Marilyn photos at my main website.

Temple Tuesday: Inside Temple’s Temple

All three of Shirley Temple’s childhood residences still stand, but none compare to the one that the Temple family commissioned at the height of their daughter’s fame. It even graced the cover of House Beautiful! According to Melissa, aka “The Colonel”:

Once Shirley rose to fame, the house in Santa Monica could not afford her the privacy she required, so the Temples purchased land in the Brentwood Park section of Los Angeles in late 1935, and construction began in March 1936. The lot measured 168' x 400', and the property ran from Rockingham Avenue all the way to Sunset Boulevard. They moved into the approximately 5,000 square foot residence later that summer. On June 30, 1936 they bought additional land to the south, bringing their property to a total of more than three acres. The main home was designed by John Byers of Santa Monica and his associate, Edla Muir.



Thanks to a previous visit and connection she had made to the current owners, Melissa was able to take me along this time when she traveled West and got a second opportunity to see Temple’s Temple.



If you compare my contemporary shot (above) with the vintage view below, you’ll see that the exterior looks virtually the same, except for one minor thing: the left-hand side is completely missing. Yup. It’s true. Gonzo. More on that later!



Here’s Shirley on the front porch with English actress, singer, comedian Gracie Fields, getting ready to celebrate her eighth birthday in 1937 with a gigantic cake for the cameras. Actually, it was her ninth, but at the time, Shirley was told otherwise.



Here’s a video clip of the occasion:



It is still hard to believe that I was actually there.



I am so glad I had my 600mm lens with me to get this detailed shot of the original weathervane:



The proud owners of this beloved property who generously opened it up to us one lovely Friday afternoon:



Recognize the door in the vintage shot below with Shirley and then husband John Agar? Other than the paint color and some different plants, all looks the same!



In this 1940 image for LIFE Magazine, Shirley descends the spiral staircase in the foyer:



There was no debutante ball for me, but I was probably just as excited as Shirley was over 80 years ago!



Same glass finial!



I was obsessed with this staircase…



AND the vintage chandelier!



Shirley in her bedroom:



How it looks today:



The homeowner is looking over the book that Melissa, Rita Dubas (Shirley expert supreme!), and I put together with the history of her home, chock full of photos, articles, and vintage floor plans:



Shirley dusts her bedroom shelf:



The same location today:



Two vintage shots of Shirley’s Playroom:



Plenty of room for play!



The room is just as impressive today, with its original wooden beams overhead:



It appeared that only one of the bathrooms in the home had the original tile. I just about died when I peaked into this one, as vintage tile gets me every time.



Shirley dances down the steps in the backyard that lead to the pool:



Still there!



Near the pool is Shirley’s glass playhouse, built and gifted by the Owens-Illinois Glass Company. According to the press release of the time:

Partial partitioning provides for a miniature kitchen, bedroom and a living room. Removable doors make it possible to ‘open up’ the entire front whenever desired. A candy pole porch column and murals of storybook characters add to the fun of housekeeping.



Still there!



In this photo, Shirley assisted with the construction:



How that area looks today:



The Temples sold the home in 1951; at some point later, the owner decided to split the main house into two, most likely to make the property easier to sell. Thus, the missing section of the home shown in my earlier photos. This shot shows the portion that was removed:



The other remaining half next door and how it looks today:



What a day! The gang stands outside the entry gate as we get ready to depart:



The same gate!





Thanks to Melissa for getting me into Temple’s Temple and extra special thanks to the hospitality of the current owners!

See more Shirley Temple photos at my main website.

Temple Tuesday: Shirley in the Kitchen

In the November 1939 issue of the Swedish magazine Vecko-Revyn (which translates to “Weekly-Revue”), there was a one-page article on Shirley titled “Little Princess In The Kitchen.” The name of the story was timely as Shirley’s movie, “The Little Princess” had recently been showing in theaters; the photos for the story were not so timely, as they were shot two years before in 1937.

Here are the photos from the story along with the translated copy:

First, Shirley takes a look at the cookbook - so often does the most skilled cook, they say.

Wow, should it be this smeary? Maybe I read it wrong, Shirley thinks.

If you take a little more flour, it will soon be better…

You can get too much of that, too!!!

Rolling out the dough is just about the most fun of all.

And punching out the biscuits with a round cutter is not so bad either…look! Here they are and not a single one was burned!

A child who knows everything is usually a horror to their peers and is called a little old and stuffy by the older ones. Little Shirley Temple is in any case a delightful example of the opposite, even though she knows most things already at the age of 10: she sings like a happy lark, she dances and steps better than most, she acts in front of the film camera so naturally, that one could say a lot of Hollywood's adult stars would benefit from taking some private lessons from her. And besides all this, she's so cute! What more can you ask of a lady at that age? And now there are new pictures, which show that the little artist can bake too! But for all Swedish children who get inferiority complexes from seeing this, her latest triumph, and become jealous. Whisper this in their ear: we do not think Shirley baked all this alone - her mother was certainly  there and helped when the photographer was not looking.

A few pages later, the magazine reported on Shirley’s recent trip to Hawaii. Once again, they used a photo that was from many years before to illustrate.

While the Swedish audience enjoys Shirley Temple as "Little Princess,” so she herself has had a vacation and gone with mom and dad to Honolulu.

 See more Shirley Temple photos at my main website.